Somms on toms: pairing wine with tomatoes

Somms on toms: pairing wine with tomatoes

Somms on toms: pairing wine with tomatoes

by Fiona Sims20 June 2023

There's somewhat of a misconception that tomatoes are tricky to pair with wine but if you know what you're doing, there are plenty of wonderful combinations to be found. Fiona Sims guides us through the art of pairing tomatoes with wine, with insight from some of the UK's top sommeliers. 

Somms on toms: pairing wine with tomatoes

There's somewhat of a misconception that tomatoes are tricky to pair with wine but if you know what you're doing, there are plenty of wonderful combinations to be found. Fiona Sims guides us through the art of pairing tomatoes with wine, with insight from some of the UK's top sommeliers. 

Fiona Sims is a leading food, drink, travel writer and editor. She contributes to many magazines and newspapers including The Times and The Sunday Times, Decanter, Delicious and National Geographic Food, and travels the world in pursuit of top chefs, pioneering food producers, hot hotels and legendary winemakers, brewers, and distillers.

Fiona Sims is a leading food, drink, travel writer and editor. She contributes to many magazines and newspapers including The Times and The Sunday Times, Decanter, Delicious and National Geographic Food, and travels the world in pursuit of top chefs, pioneering food producers, hot hotels and legendary winemakers, brewers, and distillers. Fiona is also the author of several food and wine books, including best-seller, The Boat Cookbook, and The Boat Drinks Book, both published by Bloomsbury. You can read more about her at the2fionas.com.

Fiona Sims is a leading food, drink, travel writer and editor. She contributes to many magazines and newspapers including The Times and The Sunday Times, Decanter, Delicious and National Geographic Food, and travels the world in pursuit of top chefs, pioneering food producers, hot hotels and legendary winemakers, brewers, and distillers.

Fiona Sims is a leading food, drink, travel writer and editor. She contributes to many magazines and newspapers including The Times and The Sunday Times, Decanter, Delicious and National Geographic Food, and travels the world in pursuit of top chefs, pioneering food producers, hot hotels and legendary winemakers, brewers, and distillers. Fiona is also the author of several food and wine books, including best-seller, The Boat Cookbook, and The Boat Drinks Book, both published by Bloomsbury. You can read more about her at the2fionas.com.

Everyone has a tomato and wine moment - don’t they? Mine was sitting at the counter in Portuguese small plates restaurant Bar Douro in London’s Borough, savouring a simple salad of the sweetest heritage tomatoes dressed in a white port vinaigrette. Owner Max Graham poured a ‘Nat Cool’ – a natural wine from Douro winery Pormenor (which he sells from his wine shop wearefesta.co.uk) – a light-bodied red called ‘Ginga’ made with a ‘field blend’, its plummy notes working handsomely with the tomatoes, the acidity well-matched, while the wine’s savoury flavours dialled up the umami in the tomatoes. Wine nerdery, I know, but it really did hit the spot, and it blows a long-held myth that tomatoes are a tad tricky when it comes to pairing with wine.

Now that we are in the full throes of summer, tomatoes are on every menu, served every which way. But what to drink with them? Well, there is lots to choose from. Just work out how you will be preparing your tomatoes - raw or cooked, a sweet dressing, or with cheese, then take it from there. And pay attention to the intensity of the dish as your wine match should equal that level of intensity if you want to balance those flavours. Plus, some kitchen alchemy to note: acidic foods make wines taste less acidic, so tart wines will taste fruiter when paired with tomatoes, while richer wines will lean towards the flabby. Which leads to another consideration, there are many different varieties of tomatoes out there, boasting lots of different flavours - more than 10,000 in fact. Just saying. One more thing to think about - what else will be on the plate? If it’s grilled tomatoes with a big juicy steak, say, then it’s the meat you need to be matching.

Don’t want to spend too long thinking about it? Then how about following Isa Bal’s lead? The multi-award-winning Turkish ex-Fat Duck sommelier at London’s Trivet restaurant suggests, as a rule of thumb, looking at countries that eat a lot of tomatoes (Spain, Italy et al), then just choose a wine from there to match. Simples. 'Rioja always works well with tomato-based dishes, as do most Italian wines, however they’re cooked,' explains Bal. 'I swear by Sangiovese, which is the grape behind Chianti – I find that it works brilliantly with pretty much any cooked tomato dish.'

Consider umami. Yes, tomatoes boast lots of it (add Parmesan and you can double that). For the ultimate tomato umami hit consider pairing them with a wine similarly endowed. On that note, I’ve always loved fino sherry with tomatoes, however they come. The savoury, nutty, salty character of the sherry does a little dance when paired with tomatoes, roasted, or as a salad, dressed with olive oil and salt. For Bal, though, it’s sake. 'Though I’m talking premium sake here, a junmai or junmai daiginjo, served nice and chilled,' he advises.

Trivet co-founder and sommelier, Isa Bal. Photography by Jodi Hinds

Sandia Chang, the Californian sommelier and beverage director at the two Michelin-starred Kitchen Table restaurant in Marylebone, is also rather partial to pairing tomatoes with sake to up those umami levels. But she has found her quintessential tomato-friendly wine a little nearer to home, in Mosel Riesling. 'When it’s a cold salad preparation, I love Riesling. Or to be more specific, Rudolf and Rita Trossen’s Schieferblume Riesling – it goes with every single kind of tomato dish,' she reveals. 'I also love white wine from the Rhône Valley, such as Marsanne or Condrieu. And for both salads and cooked tomato dishes, look at light reds, such as Gamay from Beaujolais.'

Though the match closest to home of all is English sparkling wine, believes Spring sommelier, South Africa-born Monique Ziervogel, where chef-owner Skye Gyngell serves up a roster of punchy dishes bursting with fresh, zesty flavours at her restaurant in London’s iconic Somerset House. 'It’s just great with raw tomato dishes,' she says, citing Oxney sparkling rosé with gazpacho as a standout pairing. 'Another favourite is Greek wine Gaia’s wild ferment Assyrtiko, with Skye’s guinea fowl served with raw tomatoes and anchovy butter,' she adds.

It turns out Ziervogel is rather fond of curve balls. 'Skye uses a lot of tomatoes in her cooking, so I’ve had a lot of experience finding interesting wines to pair with those dishes,' she explains. On a recent visit, Ziervogel offered a clever pairing of Ezio Poggio’s fresh, minerally Timorasso from the Piedmont with a pork tonnato topped with intense yellow Southern Italian datterini tomatoes (the latter easily the dominant flavour), but it was the salmon-hued, pomegranate-scented skin contact Pinot Grigio Fuoripista from Trentino winemaker Elisabetta Foradori that won the day with a dish of monkfish and clams in a richly flavoured tomato-based stew, with fennel, rosemary and aioli. In fact, skin contact wines in general offer yet another rich source of pairing possibilities with tomato dishes, their famously savoury and gently tannic profile enhancing the match.

Sandia Chang, sommelier and beverage director at Kitchen Table
Spring sommelier, Monique Ziervogel

Ziervogel’s most ‘out there’ pairing, though, goes to Tsitska from Georgia, an indigenous variety typically packed with notes of quince, melon, and honey, which she declares another great all-rounder with tomatoes. 'You need wine with good acidity and a freshness to it, and this has it all,' she says. 'It even works with delicate tomato water, which Skye serves a lot.'

Tomatoes are versatile, sure, and they change their flavour profile dramatically depending on how they are served, from the fresh acidity of the simplest raw preparations to the unfurling sweetness of slow cooking, which further increases the range of wines with pairing potential, but there are a few wines to sidestep, namely big tannic reds, and oaky Chardonnays, which jar uncomfortably. 'I also find high acidity white wines tend not to go with tomatoes too well,' adds Chang. 'The acidity from tomatoes tends to be quite high already, what you need is something to balance it out.'

Me? I prefer my tomatoes with white wines that have a distinct minerality and savoury character to them, rosé too, especially from Provence – you can’t beat it with a tomato salad, the olive oil cleverly softening the acidity. While bubbles go with pretty much everything in my view, the tomatoes highlighting the wine’s fruit flavours. And not forgetting the odd light-bodied red ‘field blend’ from the Douro.

3 must-try tomato pairings

Sandia Chang, Kitchen Table: Panzanella, with 2000 Jean-Baptiste Souillard Marsanne, Rhône, France

Isa Bal, Trivet: A simple tomato salad, with bread, salt, extra virgin olive oil, with 2022 Pieropan Soave Classic, Veneto, Italy

Monique Ziervogel, Spring: Bucatini all’Amatriciana, with 2022 Cos Frappato, Sicily, Italy